The Legend of Zelda: The Lampshade of no Real Significance Part 4 - Getting The Very Next Two Items

Go back to the well and talk to Dan, he will use the vase to get water. He notices there is a frog in the vase, then gives it to you. Go left and then go North. There should be a NewGrounds building there, go to the man next to it, and talk to him, he is Snake, and he will eat the frog, in return you get "Tiger Face Paints".